Text
Msgs may be autodialed. Consent to texts not required to purchase our svcs. Msg. and data rates may apply.
Our Catering Menu
Delivery Available
All Our Food is Made Fresh, To Order
All Our Food is Made Fresh From Locally Sourced Ingredients
Call or Text
Catering Appointments are Available Anytime
Request Catering Quote
Hero Request Form
Thank you for contacting us.
We will get back to you as soon as possible
Please try again later
Discover Appleton Catering's Exquisite Menu
Appleton Catering, a small, local, family, and woman-owned business serving the New Castle County, DE area, offers an array of delectable American and Italian dishes. Our small, family-owned business prides itself on crafting homemade dishes without preservatives, ensuring fresh, high-quality food.
With over 25 years of food industry experience, we cater to your needs with in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery options.
Call or text us today to explore our catering services.
Why Hire Appleton Catering?
Established in 2005, Appleton Catering specializes in American and Italian cuisine for events of all sizes. There are lots of reasons why you should hire us to cater your upcoming celebration or meeting:
- In-store pickup, curbside pickup, or delivery
- Locally sourced ingredients
- Private dining rooms
- Catering appointments available anytime
- Convenient service
- Flexible hours
- Holiday meals
Let's start making plans for your next gathering. Call or text Appleton Catering today to work on your menu!
Contact Us
Ready to elevate your event with Appleton Catering? Get in touch with us to discuss your catering needs. We are available for catering appointments anytime. Let us help make your event unforgettable with our fresh, homemade dishes. Prices are subject to change.
All of Our Food is Made Fresh, to Order
Arrange for catering services today!
Reviews
Related Catering Services
Menu
Chilled Appetizers
Loaded with veggies & seasonal fruits
Loaded with veggies – Served with ranch dressing for dipping
Assorted cheeses with dipping mustard
Perfectly ripe seasonal fruits, year-round
Made up of fresh vegetables, pepperoni & cheese, and fresh fruit
Italian delicacies - pepper shooters stuffed with prosciutto and sharp provolone, Italian bruschetta, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and cured Capicola ham
Carved into a basket or baby carriage, served with 15lbs. of fruit salad
A classic with Old Bay seasoning, served with an assortment of crackers
Jumbo shrimp with house-made cocktail sauce
Hot Appetizers
Served with house-made cocktail sauce
Made with a classic brown gravy swirled with sour cream
Mini meatballs in our own garlic marinara sauce
Sautéed sweet sausage, delicious
A full 5 lbs., served with BBQ sauce
Glazed with BBQ sauce
Savory and delicious - ask about available varieties
Spinach and feta cheese wrapped in filo dough
Fresh mushrooms filled with crab imperial and crab meat
Fresh mushrooms filled with our spinach and feta filling
Green Salads
Romaine and spring mix lettuces with cherry tomatoes, shredded carrot and fresh cucumber with Ranch & Balsamic vinaigrette
Fresh crisp hearts of romaine, delicious dressing and homemade croutons
Italian meats, cheeses and condiments over fresh romaine, served with balsamic vinaigrette
Granny smith apples, walnuts, dried cranberries and applewood smoked bacon over mixed greens and baby spinach - maple dijon vinaigrette
Prepared Salads
Classic Pennsylvania Dutch style
Just slightly on the sweet side
Tri-colored spirals mixed with fresh veggies and a sweet and tangy dressing
Perfectly ripe, seasonal fruits
With a little diced apple for sweetness
We only use Hellmann's mayo, celery and seasoning
Diced gulf shrimp, mayo, celery
Sliced cucumbers, tomatoes and onions served in our cucumber salad dressing
Orzo, feta, tomatoes, artichoke hearts, red roasted peppers, cucumbers and red onion
Beef Entrées
Two meatballs is enough for a small sandwich
Sliced thin, served with homemade beef gravy and fresh horseradish, enough for 5 small sandwiches
Our Top Round Roast Beef seasoned with plum tomatoes, rosemary and roasted garlic, enough for 5 small sandwiches
(10 lb. of Texas BBQ is enough to make 30-35 small sandwiches) Mouth-watering - Like eating ribs without the bone
Absolutely delicious - enough for 4 small sandwiches
Served with our house steak gravy, enough for 4 sandwiches
(Minimum of 24) 5 oz. buffet cuts priced per cut, ask about pricing
4 oz. buffet steaks priced per cut, ask about pricing
Includes burger buns, cheese, and condiment tray (lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles)
Includes bun, ketchup, mustard and relish
Chicken & Turkey Entrées
Chicken breast baked in a cream sauce topped with crabmeat
Lightly herbed with a country chicken gravy
Topped with mushrooms and a sweet Marsala wine sauce
Baked in a fabulous Dijon cream sauce
Freshly squeezed lemon and freshly picked rosemary make this dish exceptional
Topped with homemade marinara, freshly grated parmesan and shredded provolone
30 pcs. of chicken glazed with sweet and tangy BBQ sauce
Enough to make 5 small sandwiches with homemade gravy
Pork Entrées
Slow cooked with traditional BBQ sauce, enough to make 4 small sandwiches
"Italian Style" vinegar based and pepperoncinis, enough for 4 small sandwiches
Traditional Italian dish with fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oil, serves 16-20
With basil and garlic and Italian seasonings, enough to make 4-5 small sandwiches
Hand sliced with a pineapple-honey glaze, enough for 4 sandwiches
Seafood Entrées
Handmade crabcakes
Topped with spinach, feta and parmesan cheeses
Garlic-butter sauce over pasta, serves 16-20 for dinner, 25-40 as a side dish
Penne with crabmeat and shrimp topped with our fabulous lobster sauce, serves 12-16 for dinner, 25-40 as a side dish
Pasta
Made with mozzarella, parmesan and marinara, serves 25-40
Four cheeses with a delicious parmesan-cream sauce, serves 25-40
A "blush" sauce made with tomatoes, cream, and parmesan cheese, serves 25-40
Sun dried tomatoes, mushrooms, cream, white wine, and herbs, serves 25-40
A blend of white Cheddar, provolone, smoked gouda, and parmesan cheeses, serves 25-40
Made with white and yellow Cheddar cheeses, serves 25-40
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
Vegetables & Potatoes
25 portions
Lightly browned butter and a dash of salt and pepper, 25 portions
Made with butter, bacon, and toasted almonds, 25 portions
Glazed with brown sugar and honey, 25 portions
Oven roasted vegetables with butter and fresh herbs, 25 portions
With butter and a hint of garlic, 25 portions
Simmered in chicken broth with fresh rosemary, 25 portions
Oven roasted and seasoned with Old Bay, 25 portions
Absolutely delicious, 25 portions
Made with Smoked Gouda cheese, 25 portions
Pan-fried eggplant rolled with ricotta center and marinara, 25 pcs.
Mashed sweet potatoes with a cinnamon streusel topping, 25 portions
Creamy & delicious, 25 portions
Loaded with herbs & seasoning
Boxed Lunches & Sandwiches
Choose from Turkey, Roast Beef, Ham, Chicken Salad, and Tuna Salad Sandwiches with an apple, potato chips, cookie, and a beverage
Turkey & Swiss, roast beef and provolone, ham & cheddar, and one of our delicious salad spreads, made with tri-color flour tortillas
Turkey & Swiss, roast beef and provolone, ham & cheddar, and one of our delicious salad spreads
Desserts
A delicious variety, serves 25-35
A delicious assortment of our pastry chef's mini desserts, approx. 80 pcs.
Wrapped chocolates, chocolate nuts, chocolate creams, and more, 25-30 portions
Made by Pellmans of Lancaster County
Made by Pellmans of Lancaster County
Made by Pellmans of Lancaster County
Made by Pellmans of Lancaster County
Made by Pellmans of Lancaster County
Chocolate brownies or walnut brownies or a combination of both
A delicious assortment of cookies & brownies, 25-35
Breakfast
The Marshallton Steakhouse Brunch Favorite
Savory & Delicious, Ask about available varieties
Crispy Strips
Assortment of Breakfast Treats
Beverages
Regular, diet, bottled water and ice
Sweetened or unsweetened 75 servings, 5-gallon thermal container with sweeteners & lemon
75 servings, 5-gallon thermal container
Regular coffee served in air pots with half & half, sweeteners, cups, spoons, napkins
Regular coffee served in air pots with half & half, sweeteners, cups, spoons, napkins
50 lb. cooler of extra party ice
Buffet Equipment
Chinet plates, napkins, cups and all plastic cutlery
Upscale disposable plates, includes stainless steel flatware, dinner napkins, and beverage cups, great for a home party or casual wedding
Stainless steel chafing dishes include all equipment for your buffet (Sterno fuel, salad bowls, bread baskets, serving spoons, tongs, ladles, etc.)
For all of your tents, tables, and chair rentals, we highly recommend Diamond State Party Rental
Prices subject to change.
Learn More About
Appleton Catering
Serving the New Castle County, DE area, Appleton Catering specializes in catering service and buffet packages for weddings and other events. All our food is made fresh from locally sourced ingredients. Delivery and pickup options. No preservatives. Call today.
Appleton Catering at The Marshallton Steakhouse Location
Appleton Catering at Booths Corner Farmers Market location
1362 Naamans Creek Rd
Garnet Valley, DE 19060
302-992-0998
Friday and Saturday: 9:00 am-8:00 pm
Holiday Hours May Vary
Share On: